Mythic Mischief Vol. I vs Vol. II: Which Volume Do You Need?
By IV Studio — Shop Tend, Moonrakers, Veiled Fate, and Mythic | Published: 2026-10-31
Category: Comparisons
Compare Mythic Mischief Vol. I and Vol. II by setting, player count, and price. Learn which volume to start with and when to add the other.
Quick answer
Start with Mythic Mischief Vol. I if you want the S'ghoul Library setting and the lower-priced entry point. Choose Vol. II if the Hedgemaze theme appeals more or you already own Vol. I and want a second board. Both support 1–4 players and share the same core hijinks, so your choice comes down to setting and budget.
The real difference is the board, not the rulebook
Both volumes are standalone games in the same Mythic Mischief line. The core loop is identical: groups of Mythics with contrasting powers manipulate the board to outmaneuver opponents and catch them in the path of a bone-chilling keeper. What changes is the setting—Vol. I takes place in the S'ghoul Library with the Tomekeeper, while Vol. II moves to the Hedgemaze with the Hedgekeeper.
That means you are not buying a sequel with new mechanics; you are buying a different arena and the characters that fit it. If you like one theme over the other, that preference should drive your first purchase more than any rule difference.
Price and value: Vol. I is the cheaper entry
At catalog prices, Vol. I is listed at USD 43.79 and Vol. II at USD 42.59, both against a USD 59.99 comparison price. The gap is small, so do not let a dollar decide it—use the setting and whether you plan to own both. Buying the volume that matches your group's taste is the better value than chasing the lowest price.
Owning both: expansion order and overlap
These are not expansions that require the other volume to play; each is a complete 1–4 player game. If you plan to own both, pick the setting that excites your group first, then add the other as a second board for variety. Do not expect one volume to fix or complete the other—they are parallel experiences, not a campaign.
Trade-offs to weigh
- Theme vs. price: Vol. I is slightly cheaper, but the price gap is small. Pick the theme your group will actually replay—S'ghoul Library or Hedgemaze—rather than saving a dollar.
- One volume vs. both: Each volume is standalone. If you want variety, buy the one you prefer first and add the other later as a second board, not as a required expansion. Do not buy both at once unless your group already knows it loves the core loop.
- Player count is the same: Both support 1–4 players, so player count does not separate them. Base your choice on setting and whether you want a second arena.
Product facts
- Mythic Mischief Vol. II: Mythic Mischief Vol. II is set in the Hedgemaze and supports 1 to 4 players. Choose this volume if the Hedgemaze theme and its Hedgekeeper appeal to your group.
Mythic Mischief Vol. II - Mythic Mischief Vol. I: Mythic Mischief Vol. I is set in the S'ghoul Library and supports 1 to 4 players. Choose this volume if you prefer the library setting and want the lower-priced entry point.
Mythic Mischief Vol. I
Which volume fits you?
Best for
- Players who prefer the S'ghoul Library theme and want the lower-priced entry (Vol. I)
- Groups that already enjoy Vol. I and want a second board with the Hedgemaze setting (Vol. II)
Not for
- Shoppers expecting Vol. II to be a required expansion—it is a standalone game
- Groups that only want one board and do not care about theme—either volume works, so pick by price
